In a crowded meeting last night, the Board of County Commissioners reviewed and discussed the proposed interlocal implementation agreement for the recently adopted transit plan. The discussion centered around a few questions: who would be party to the agreement, who would have control over how much of the revenues brought in from the transit tax. I've excerpted the part of the more than 400-page agenda packet that concerns the agreement here for you to see the draft of the agreement itself.
Ultimately the Commission voted 5-1 to direct the staff to include DCHCMPO as a signatory in the agreement. John Roberts, the county attorney, noted that since the question of the parties to the agreement was the only major sticking point, the agreement was likely to be adopted soon.
A second major stream of conservation was around how funding from tax revenues would be allocated between maintaining or expanding existing service and creating new service. Chapel Hill Town Council Member Jim Ward and Chapel Hill Transit Director Steve Spade were both on hand to say that Chapel Hill Transit Committee (the towns of Chapel Hill and Carrboro plus UNC) could not support the current interlocal agreement because it doesn't offer them enough flexibility in spending.
Though the conversation got quite detailed and technical and went on for some time, Commissioner Pelissier made the interesting comment that she was concerned that UNC wasn't putting enough into the system which it will greatly benefit from.
Other topics at the meeting included the siting criteria for the new Southern Branch Library, several rezoning applications and the adjustment of MPO boundaries to be inline with the 2010 Census. For more detailed descriptions of theses conversations, see my live tweets on Storify , but I did want to highlight two.
First, Commission Hemminger called on the Board to write a letter of support urging Chancellor Holden Thorp to stay in his post. No action on this item was taken. It was referred to the agenda review process, which presumably means it will come up at one of the next few regular meetings.
Second, a member of public got up at the beginning of the meeting and accused the commissioners of committing high treason and acting in league with a Communist environmental organization on the Mountains-to-Sea Trail project. Toward the end of the meeting, county Department of Environment, Agriculture, Parks and Recreation Director David Stancil rebutted the resident's claims by pointing out that none of the trail had yet been laid, and by noting that the trail's route for the most park is simply the quickest way to get between state parks.
See Twitter coverage of the meeting below.
[View the story "BOCC Regular Meeting, September 18, 2012" on Storify ]BOCC Regular Meeting, September 18, 2012 The Commissioners consider several rezoning applications, the siting of the Southern Branch Library, MPO boundaries and the interlocal implementation agreement for transit among other things. Storified by OrangePolitics · Tue, Sep 18 2012 21:20:47
This is @jdmiles312 live tweeting tonight's #BOCC meeting. Room is crowded, we're about to be called to order.OrangePolitics
Meeting called to order #BOCCOrangePolitics
Frank Clifton introducing new public info officier #BOCCOrangePolitics
Petition from a Member of the Public : Resident accuses Commissioners of committing high treason and being in league with communist organizations.
Resident complaining about using tax dollars for environmental group, accusing commissioners of land grab #BOCCOrangePolitics
Resident says commissioners are committing treason #BOCCOrangePolitics
Two Side Notes
Hemminger: #BOCC should write letter of support for #Thorp to stay as #UNC chancellorOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics Quite a strange circumstance . . .Chris Moran
@orangepolitics what did they decide in that?Molly De Marco
@mollsdemarco It was a "petition by a commissioner" so it's referred to the agenda process for the next regular meeting #BOCCOrangePolitics
Note: Commissioner Foushee is not present #BOCCOrangePolitics
Awarding of Arts Grants : The
Orange County Arts Commission awarded more that $30,000 in grants to local artists and arts organizations. Commissioners handed out checks to representatives from each winner.
#Orange #Arts Commish staff person: county gave $30k in money (mostly from @NCArtsCouncil); recipients are present #BOCCOrangePolitics
Checks being distributed to #arts groups reps #BOCCOrangePolitics
Local gov supporting the arts! RT @orangepolitics: Checks being distributed to #arts groups reps #BOCCWill McInerney
RT @will_mci: Local gov supporting the arts! RT @orangepolitics: Checks being distributed to #arts groups reps #BOCCSacrificial Poets
Grant recipients include several #PTAs, @ncsymphony, several galleries #BOCCOrangePolitics
Consent Agenda : Commissioner Hemminger raises concerns over an usually high level of property tax releases.
Consent agenda minus item 5d passes unanimously #BOCCOrangePolitics
Hemminger questions large amount of property tax releases; tax administrator explain #BOCCOrangePolitics
Releases (item 5d) passes; turning to Spence Dickinson rezoning #BOCCOrangePolitics
Three Rezoning Applications : Commissioners rezone two properties. One will be combined with an adjoining property and remain largely undeveloped, another will be used for solar power. A third case was referred back to the Planning Board for further discussion.
County attorney says #BOCC shouldn't let property owner to speak b/c that would allow the decision the board makes to be overturned in courtOrangePolitics
Continued back in forth between #BOCC members and planning dept staff about what decision they are makingOrangePolitics
#BOCC closes public hearing and rezones property to rural bufferOrangePolitics
#BOCC now considering rezoning for solar energy in property off White Cross RoadOrangePolitics
RT @orangepolitics: #BOCC now considering rezoning for solar energy in property off White Cross RoadStephanie Daugherty
Through several different motions, #BOCC unanimously approves rezoning to allow for solar developmentOrangePolitics
Now discussing rezoning of a property to an #EconomicDevelopment district #BOCCOrangePolitics
Planning staff detailing the site plan for the rezoning; plan is for a mini-storage #BOCCOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics Do we really need another mini-storage ANYWHERE? Seems like there's too many of them, and they waste a lot of space...Stephanie Daugherty
Hemminger expresses concern that applicant will truck in water for cleaning and not have a well #BOCCOrangePolitics
Engineer representing the applicant says that a well is too expensive and not needed #BOCCOrangePolitics
More discussion over water source at property #BOCCOrangePolitics
#BOCC discussion on mini storage continues; Jacobs raises concerns about buffers and project design standards in #rural areasOrangePolitics
#BOCC sends rezoning back to the #planning board to consider water and buffer issuesOrangePolitics
Southern Branch Library Siting Criteria : The Commissioners approve criteria for the staff to begin a technical review of potential sites in the southern part of the county for a new branch of the Orange Public Library.
#BOCC moving to siting criteria for Southern Branch #LibraryOrangePolitics
Library branch formerly referred to as "Southwestern Branch." Adjusted to "Southern" to be inclusive. #boccCity Beautiful 21
Library director gives brief overview of library siting criteria, which will include access, capacity & visibility #BOCCOrangePolitics
Commissioner Gordon: is @CarrboroTownGov on board with these? Library dir. says no objections #BOCCOrangePolitics
Jacobs: #library should be in alignment with both county and @CarrboroTownGov plans #BOCCOrangePolitics
RT @orangepolitics: Jacobs: #library should be in alignment with both county and @CarrboroTownGov plans #BOCCDigital Storymakers
Comm. Jacobs suggests adding library site selection criterion of brownfield v. greenfield regarding sustainability #boccCity Beautiful 21
Jacobs: I have been approached about potential brownfield site in Downtown (#Carrboro, I assume) #boccCity Beautiful 21
Gordon: potential costs of construction need to be part of the equation #BOCCOrangePolitics
#BOCC voted to accept the criteria for free standing lib. for S. Orange!!!Melva Fager Okun
#BOCC approves criteria for selecting a new #library site; moving to #MPO boundariesOrangePolitics
Changes to the Burlington-Graham and Durham-Chapel Hill Carrboro MPOs : Commissioners commented on and ultimately approved changes to the boundaries of the two local MPOs. MPOs are required to revisit and adjust their boundaries after each Census.
#MPOs are redefining boundaries b/c they have to after each census #BOCCOrangePolitics
When you closely follow the Twitter feed for a #BOCC meeting, you know you work for City @chelseydulaney @katiemacreilly @ChessaDeCainJennifer Surane
RT @jennysurane: When you closely follow the Twitter feed for a #BOCC meeting, you know you work for City @chelseydulaney @katiemacreil ...Katie Reilly
Gordon: I support making the boundary changes suggested; Jacobs: #Mebane supports this plan #BOCCOrangePolitics
Jacobs: I've asked twice and still not seen the advantages & disadvantages of the various boundary options #BOCCOrangePolitics
#BOCC approves boundary changes unanimously; #MPOs will implementOrangePolitics
Interlocal Transit Implementation Agreement : Main discussions were around who would be party the agreement and how some of the funding mechanisms would work. There was also some debate as to the language around the benchmarking process for applying for state and federal funds.
#BOCC now considering a #transit implementation agreement; the biggest disagreement now is whether @DCHCMPO will be a party to itOrangePolitics
Implementation agreement = basically how the #TransitTax money will be spent #BOCCOrangePolitics
Also a cost-share agreement with #Durham and a breakdown by mode and new vs. existing service #BOCCOrangePolitics
Gordon makes intro comments on agreement #BOCCOrangePolitics
Gordon gives #BOCC background on grants, reminds that #transit plan approval was conditional & outlines agreement changes she wants to seeOrangePolitics
Town Council Member Jim Ward: @chtransit committee does not support current implementation agreement #BOCCOrangePolitics
No other members would like to speak #BOCCOrangePolitics
Hemminger suggests that @DCHCMPO should be a third party to the agreement and that all three must agree for decisions to go forward #BOCCOrangePolitics
McKee: @DCHCMPO should have an advisory role and not a signatory role, section 12 makes this impossible #BOCCOrangePolitics
Gordon: @DCHCMPO wants a specified role; there should be some text on what that role is whether or not in the agreement #BOCCOrangePolitics
.@triangletransit: money collected in excess of the plan would sit in escrow until the parties reach an agreement #BOCCOrangePolitics
Pelissier: I think it's critical that @DCHCMPO be a party to the agreement; it's part of #MPO responsibilities #BOCCOrangePolitics
Pelissier: @DCHCMPO gives @chapelhillgov, @CarrboroTownGov voices in the agreement #BOCCOrangePolitics
McKee: I don't think that the MPO should be a signatory b/c #BOCC represents the countyOrangePolitics
.@DCHCMPO rep: us not being a signatory would allow two parties to change a plan that three parties worked on #BOCCOrangePolitics
Jacobs: gov'ts are not always collaborative; having the MPO would provide a more regional view #BOCCOrangePolitics
Dialogue between @chtransit reps (Ward and Spade) and #BOCC membersOrangePolitics
.@chtransit's primary concern seems to be about flexibility in spending #BOCCOrangePolitics
Yuhasz: I don't think that @DCHCMPO's inclusion would decrease Orange County's voice #BOCCOrangePolitics
#BOCC votes 5-1 to direct staff to include @DCHCMPO as a signatory & that all parities must agree to material changes to the agreementOrangePolitics
Jacobs: @chtransit should provide some specific language that would appease its concerns for #BOCC members + staff to considerOrangePolitics
McKee: I don't think the plan is good and I wanted only 2 parties in the agreement to change the plan #BOCCOrangePolitics
Yuhasz: would @chtransit want to use the #TransitTax to make up possible funding decreases from #UNC? #BOCCOrangePolitics
Hemminger: the parties need to talk, come up w/ some specific language and funding distributions & send to #BOCC for approvalOrangePolitics
Pelissier: the concern I have is that #UNC is not contributing to this transit plan, but is going to gain immensely from it #BOCCOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics we're currently standing to increase the amount we pay per student for transit by 22 dollars each!Tim Longest
@timlongest We saw that, but part of the #BOCC concern seemed to that those increases might not be approved; not our (OP) opinion, there'sOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics it's going to pass, UNC isn't about to redo the 5 year transit plan with everything else going on...Tim Longest
@timlongest Just as an FYI, last year the full amount asked for was not approved and that's what the #BOCC was talking aboutOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics oh gotcha. I was on that committee and I believe sentiment has changed since.Tim Longest
Gordon wants to add language about benchmarks regarding state and federal funding #BOCCOrangePolitics
Hemminger, Pelissier: benchmarks and review are needed, but rigid language should be avoided #BOCCOrangePolitics
Jacobs, Yuhasz: benchmarks are needed and we need to make sure they're done specific and relatively soon #BOCCOrangePolitics
McKee: the county should maintain control over any additional revenues above those forecasted #BOCCOrangePolitics
Jacobs, Pelissier: If it's partnership, it's a partnership; if it's not, it's not; #BOCC does not add that language inOrangePolitics
Gordon: benchmarks need to be included for both state and federal funding, b/c state accounts for 25% #BOCCOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics lucky I'm not there because I would have screamedGerry Cohen
Gordon: definition of "material" changes should be much smaller #BOCCOrangePolitics
#Transit discussion closes and so will our tweets; remaining: an update on @NCMST, appointments to boards. Goodnight! #BOCCOrangePolitics
@orangepolitics thanks for the tweets Jeff.Geoff Green
@geoff_green Thanks for following!OrangePolitics